Updated by Saransh Kanaujia on 16 October 2026
India’s independence on 15 August 1947 was the
culmination of a long and complex struggle against British colonial rule. The
movement involved constitutional politics, mass mobilisation, non-violent
resistance, revolutionary activities, wartime developments and growing
political consciousness among soldiers, workers, students, farmers and ordinary
citizens.
Among the personalities associated with the final phase of
this struggle, Subhas Chandra Bose and the Indian National Army (INA)
occupy a distinctive place. Bose believed that British rule could not be
removed through constitutional negotiations and non-violent resistance alone.
During the Second World War, he sought international assistance and attempted
to build an armed force capable of fighting the British in India.
The INA ultimately failed to achieve a military victory, but
its political and psychological impact was substantial. The subsequent INA
trials of 1945–46, followed by unrest within sections of the Indian armed
forces and the Royal Indian Navy revolt of 1946, contributed to a wider
crisis of confidence in the continuation of British rule.
At the same time, it would be historically inaccurate to
attribute Indian independence exclusively to Bose, the INA, the revolutionaries
or any single movement. India’s freedom emerged from the interaction of several
forces operating over decades.
Subhas Chandra Bose: A Different Vision of Independence
Subhas Chandra Bose was one of the most prominent
nationalist leaders of the twentieth century. Born in Cuttack in 1897, he
became increasingly critical of the pace and methods of constitutional
politics.
Bose initially worked within the Indian National Congress
but eventually developed major differences with its leadership over strategy
and the question of how rapidly India should pursue complete independence.
He served as Congress president in 1938 and was re-elected
in 1939. However, disagreements with the Congress leadership eventually led to
his resignation.
Bose subsequently established the Forward Bloc and
sought to organise a broader nationalist struggle.
His central conviction was that the Second World War created
an opportunity to challenge British rule. If Britain was weakened by the war,
Bose believed that an organised Indian military force could potentially
contribute to India’s liberation.
Bose’s International Campaign During World War II
During the Second World War, Bose left India and eventually
reached Germany, where he attempted to obtain international support for India’s
independence.
He later travelled to Southeast Asia, where he assumed
leadership of the Indian independence movement among sections of the Indian
diaspora and Indian prisoners of war.
British intelligence records document Bose’s efforts to
encourage an armed revolt in India and his attempts to build an Indian military
force with Axis assistance.
This association with Germany and Japan remains an important
and controversial aspect of Bose’s historical legacy. Bose’s primary objective
was Indian independence, but his wartime strategy involved cooperation with
governments that were themselves pursuing expansionist and authoritarian
objectives.
The Indian National Army
The Indian National Army, popularly known as the INA
or Azad Hind Fauj, had its origins among Indian prisoners of war captured by
the Japanese during the fall of Singapore.
The organisation was subsequently reorganised under Bose’s
leadership after he arrived in Southeast Asia.
Bose gave the INA a powerful political identity and sought
to transform it into an army of national liberation.
The INA operated alongside Japanese forces in the Burma and
northeastern India theatre. Its most important military campaign was associated
with the Japanese offensive toward Imphal and Kohima in 1944.
The campaign ultimately failed. Japanese and INA forces
faced enormous logistical difficulties, disease, shortages of food and
ammunition, difficult terrain and determined Allied resistance.
The defeat prevented the INA from achieving its objective of
entering India and initiating a wider uprising.
Why the INA Still Became Important
The significance of the INA cannot be measured only by its
battlefield success.
Its existence challenged the colonial narrative that Indian
soldiers were naturally loyal to the British Empire. The INA demonstrated that
some Indian soldiers were willing to change sides and fight under an explicitly
nationalist banner.
This became particularly significant after the war when INA
personnel returned to India as prisoners and defendants.
The Provisional Government of Azad Hind
Bose proclaimed the Provisional Government of Free India,
commonly known as the Azad Hind government, in October 1943.
It claimed to represent an independent India and received
recognition from several Axis-aligned governments.
The government also established administrative structures
and sought to demonstrate that an alternative Indian state could exist outside
British control.
Although its practical territorial and administrative
control was limited, the Azad Hind government had considerable symbolic
importance.
It provided Bose’s movement with an institutional identity
beyond that of a military organisation.
The INA Trials at the Red Fort
One of the most important consequences of the INA’s defeat
came after the Second World War.
The British government decided to prosecute selected INA
officers.
The first major trial involved:
- Shah
Nawaz Khan - Prem
Kumar Sahgal - Gurbaksh
Singh Dhillon
The proceedings took place at the Red Fort in Delhi
beginning in late 1945.
The defendants faced charges including waging war against
the King-Emperor and other allegations.
The trials quickly became a national political issue.
Instead of isolating the INA personnel, the prosecutions
generated considerable public sympathy.
Congress and the INA Defence
The Indian National Congress participated in the legal and
political defence of the INA personnel.
Prominent lawyers and political figures became associated
with the defence, including:
- Bhulabhai
Desai - Jawaharlal
Nehru - Tej
Bahadur Sapru - Kailash
Nath Katju - Asaf
Ali
The participation of leaders from different political
backgrounds helped transform the trials into a broader national issue.
The INA defendants increasingly came to be viewed by large
sections of the Indian public as patriots rather than simply as soldiers who
had fought against the British Indian Army.
The first trial therefore produced an unintended political
consequence: it strengthened sympathy for the INA.
The Political Impact of the INA Trials
The INA trials had an impact beyond the courtroom.
Public demonstrations and political mobilisation occurred in
several parts of India.
The issue also cut across some of the divisions that had
increasingly characterised Indian politics.
The fact that Shah Nawaz Khan, Prem Sahgal and Gurbaksh
Singh Dhillon came from different religious backgrounds acquired symbolic
importance.
The INA therefore became associated with an image of
national unity at a time when communal tensions were becoming increasingly
serious.
The trials also raised fundamental questions about the
legitimacy of colonial rule.
If Indians could be prosecuted for fighting for India’s
independence, many Indians increasingly questioned why Britain had the right to
rule India in the first place.
The Revolutionaries and Their Contribution
The Indian freedom struggle was never confined to
constitutional politics or non-violent mass movements.
Revolutionary nationalists played an important role in
sustaining the idea of complete independence and inspiring successive
generations of Indians.
Among the important revolutionary figures were:
- Khudiram
Bose - Prafulla
Chaki - Ram
Prasad Bismil - Ashfaqulla
Khan - Chandrashekhar
Azad - Bhagat
Singh - Sukhdev
- Rajguru
- Surya
Sen - The
Chapekar brothers
Their methods varied, but many believed that British
authority had to be actively challenged rather than merely petitioned.
Revolutionary Organisations
Several organisations emerged during the revolutionary phase
of the freedom movement.
Anushilan Samiti
Anushilan Samiti became one of the major revolutionary
organisations in Bengal. It promoted physical training and nationalist activism
and was associated with revolutionary activities against British authority.
Jugantar
Jugantar developed as another important revolutionary
network in Bengal.
Its members participated in underground activities and
attempts to challenge colonial rule through armed resistance.
Hindustan Republican Association
The Hindustan Republican Association (HRA) emerged in
northern India during the 1920s.
Its members included revolutionary nationalists such as Ram
Prasad Bismil and Ashfaqulla Khan.
The organisation later developed into the Hindustan
Socialist Republican Association (HSRA).
Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev and Rajguru
Bhagat Singh became one of the most influential symbols of
revolutionary nationalism.
Along with Sukhdev Thapar and Shivaram Rajguru,
Bhagat Singh was executed by the British government in 1931.
Bhagat Singh’s importance extended beyond his willingness to
sacrifice his life.
His writings demonstrated that his political thinking
included questions of:
- Social
equality - Economic
justice - Imperialism
- Political
freedom - Secularism
- The
future social structure of India
His transformation from a revolutionary youth into a
politically sophisticated thinker made his legacy particularly influential
among Indian students and young nationalists.
The Chittagong Armoury Raid
Another major revolutionary episode was the Chittagong
Armoury Raid of 1930, led by Surya Sen, popularly known as Masterda.
The objective was to seize weapons and disrupt British
authority in Chittagong.
Although the revolutionaries could not establish permanent
control over the area, the operation demonstrated that organised armed
resistance against British rule remained possible.
The movement also included several young revolutionaries,
including women who participated in subsequent revolutionary activities.
The Chittagong movement became an important part of the
revolutionary tradition in Bengal.
The Royal Indian Navy Revolt of 1946
The Royal Indian Navy (RIN) revolt of February 1946 was
one of the most important events in the final phase of British rule.
The uprising began at HMIS Talwar in Bombay on 18
February 1946 and rapidly spread to other naval establishments and ships.
British parliamentary records confirm that the initial
refusal of duty at HMIS Talwar quickly expanded to other naval facilities and
ships in Bombay.
The revolt eventually involved thousands of Indian naval
ratings and spread beyond Bombay to places including Karachi and Calcutta.
Recent historical assessments put the number of
participating personnel at more than 20,000, with dozens of ships
involved.
Why Did the Naval Revolt Begin?
The revolt had multiple causes.
1. Racial discrimination
Indian sailors complained about discriminatory treatment by
British officers.
2. Poor food and living conditions
Food quality, accommodation and service conditions were
major grievances.
3. Demobilisation after World War II
The end of the war created uncertainty for many servicemen.
4. Political nationalism
Nationalist ideas had spread among sections of the armed
forces.
5. Influence of the INA
The INA trials generated considerable political interest and
sympathy.
6. Broader anti-colonial sentiment
The revolt occurred in an environment already affected by
wartime hardship, political mobilisation and growing opposition to British
rule.
The Government of India’s Azadi Ka Amrit Mahotsav repository
also identifies discrimination, poor facilities and dissatisfaction with
British treatment among the causes of the naval revolt.
The Naval Revolt and the Question of Military Loyalty
The significance of the 1946 naval revolt lay partly in its
implications for Britain’s ability to rely upon Indian military personnel.
The British Empire depended heavily on Indian soldiers and
sailors to maintain its authority in the subcontinent.
If significant sections of Indian servicemen could no longer
be assumed to remain politically neutral and obedient, the cost and difficulty
of maintaining colonial rule increased.
The revolt was not, however, a simple extension of the INA.
It had its own immediate causes and involved a variety of
political influences.
Therefore, historians should avoid describing the 1946 naval
revolt as merely an INA uprising.
Was the Royal Indian Navy Revolt Successful?
Militarily, the revolt was suppressed.
Political leaders including Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel
became involved in efforts to bring the confrontation to an end.
The sailors eventually surrendered.
The revolt therefore did not directly force Britain to
transfer power.
Its historical importance lies instead in what it revealed
about the changing political atmosphere within the armed forces.
The Clement Attlee–P. B. Chakraborty Account
A frequently cited claim concerns former British Prime
Minister Clement Attlee.
According to a later account attributed to P. B.
Chakraborty, who served as Chief Justice of the Calcutta High Court and
Acting Governor of West Bengal, Attlee visited India in 1956.
Chakraborty reportedly asked Attlee about the reasons behind
Britain’s decision to leave India.
According to this account, Attlee attributed major
importance to:
- Subhas
Chandra Bose - The
INA - The
weakening loyalty of Indian servicemen
An independently established historical fact.
This distinction is particularly important because
explanations for Britain’s withdrawal from India involve multiple political,
economic, military and international factors.
There is no sound historical basis for reducing the entire
process to one conversation.
Britain After the Second World War
Britain emerged from the Second World War severely weakened.
The war had:
- Increased
Britain’s financial difficulties - Reduced
imperial economic strength - Accelerated
anti-colonial movements - Changed
international attitudes toward colonialism - Increased
the political importance of self-determination - Created
enormous costs associated with maintaining the empire
The Labour government under Clement Attlee also faced a
rapidly changing international environment.
Therefore, India’s independence should be understood within
the broader post-war decline of European imperial power.
The Legacy of Subhas Chandra Bose
Subhas Chandra Bose remains one of the most admired figures
of India’s independence movement.
His famous appeal, “Give me blood, and I will give you
freedom,” captured the spirit of sacrifice that characterised his political
approach.
The INA’s military campaign failed, but its legacy survived
through public memory, political mobilisation and the symbolic power of the INA
trials.
Bose’s legacy also continues to generate historical debate
because of his wartime alliances, his political ideology and his methods.
A balanced assessment therefore requires recognition of both
his contribution to Indian nationalism and the controversies surrounding his
wartime strategy.
The Importance of the Revolutionaries
The revolutionary tradition also occupies a permanent place
in India’s freedom struggle.
From the Chapekar brothers and Khudiram Bose to Bhagat
Singh, Chandrashekhar Azad and Surya Sen, revolutionary nationalists
demonstrated that British authority faced opposition from multiple directions.
Their military operations were generally unable to overthrow
colonial rule.
However, their influence was much broader than their
immediate operational success.
They inspired political consciousness, particularly among
young Indians, and helped make the demand for complete independence
increasingly central to Indian nationalism.
Conclusion
India’s independence cannot be explained through the actions
of a single leader or a single movement.
Subhas Chandra Bose and the INA introduced a powerful
military and international dimension to the struggle. Revolutionaries inspired
generations with their willingness to sacrifice their lives for independence.
The INA trials of 1945–46 generated widespread public
sympathy, while the Royal Indian Navy revolt of 1946 exposed serious
tensions within an important section of the colonial military establishment.
Together with the enormous economic and political consequences of the Second
World War, these developments contributed to the growing difficulty of
maintaining British rule.
The most historically defensible conclusion is therefore
that India’s independence was the result of multiple forces operating over
several decades.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What was Subhas Chandra Bose’s main contribution to
India’s freedom struggle?
Subhas Chandra Bose organised the Indian National Army and
attempted to achieve India’s independence through armed struggle with
international assistance during the Second World War.
2. Did the INA defeat the British?
No. The INA’s military campaign ultimately failed,
particularly after the defeat of the Japanese offensive in the Imphal-Kohima
region. However, its political and psychological influence continued after the
war.
3. What were the INA trials?
The INA trials were military court proceedings against
selected INA personnel, most famously Shah Nawaz Khan, Prem Kumar Sahgal and
Gurbaksh Singh Dhillon. The first major trial took place at the Red Fort in
Delhi in 1945–46.
4. Why were the INA trials important?
They generated widespread public sympathy for the accused
soldiers and became a major political issue during the final phase of British
rule.
5. What was the Royal Indian Navy revolt of 1946?
It was a major uprising by Indian naval ratings that began
at HMIS Talwar in Bombay on 18 February 1946 and spread to other naval
establishments and ships.
6. Did the naval revolt alone bring independence?
No. The revolt was an important event in the final crisis of
British rule, but independence resulted from numerous political, economic,
military and international factors.
7. Did Clement Attlee say that the INA caused British
withdrawal from India?
A later account by P. B. Chakraborty attributed such remarks
to Attlee. However, the account is not supported by an independently verified
contemporary transcript and should therefore be treated as a reported statement
rather than established fact.
Latest Historical Perspective
The 80th anniversary of the Royal Indian Navy revolt in
2026 has renewed scholarly and public interest in the event. Contemporary
historical discussions increasingly place the 1946 revolt within the broader
context of wartime demobilisation, racial discrimination, military grievances,
the INA trials and the changing political consciousness of Indian servicemen.
British parliamentary records from February 1946 also
provide valuable primary evidence for reconstructing how the British government
itself viewed the naval unrest at the time.
These sources reinforce the importance of examining the
final phase of British rule through multiple forms of evidence rather than
attributing independence to one individual or one event.
Book Reference List
- Sugata
Bose — His Majesty’s Opponent: Subhas Chandra Bose and India’s
Struggle Against Empire - Leonard
A. Gordon — Brothers Against the Raj: A Biography of Indian
Nationalists Sarat and Subhas Chandra Bose - R.
C. Majumdar — History of the Freedom Movement in India - Bipan
Chandra, Mridula Mukherjee, Aditya Mukherjee, K. N. Panikkar and Sucheta
Mahajan — India’s Struggle for Independence - Sisir
Kumar Bose and Sugata Bose (eds.) — Subhas Chandra Bose: The Indian
Pilgrim - Shah
Nawaz Khan — My Memories of the I.N.A. and Its Netaji - Peter
Ward Fay — The Forgotten Army: India’s Armed Struggle for
Independence, 1942–1945 - M.
S. Jain — The Indian National Army and the Freedom Struggle - Judith
M. Brown — Modern India: The Origins of an Asian Democracy - Sumit
Sarkar — Modern India: 1885–1947
Related Articles
For related historical reading, you can explore the Matribhumi
Samachar history section and relevant articles on India’s freedom movement.
Visit
Disclaimer
This article is intended for educational and historical
informational purposes. Historical interpretations of the Indian freedom
struggle, the role of the INA, revolutionary organisations, the 1946 naval
revolt and the reasons for British withdrawal may differ among historians. The
reported conversation between Clement Attlee and P. B. Chakraborty is presented
cautiously because it is a retrospective account rather than an independently
verified contemporary transcript. Readers should consult primary documents and
scholarly historical works for detailed academic research.